John McIntyre's Blog Member of the National Association of Independent Writers and Editors
  • Home
  • Portfolio
  • Professional Profile

The Pulitzer came, and the glory shone around

May 8, 2020

On Monday of this week, The Baltimore Sun won the Pulitzer Prize for local reporting.

Its series of articles on Baltimore Mayor Catherine Pugh’s fraudulent children’s book scheme led to the mayor’s resignation and guilty plea to federal charges. Beyond that, they exposed a culture of self-dealing among board members of the University of Maryland Medical System, after which the CEO and three board members resigned, and the board was reconstituted with strict ethics procedures.

This was not the work of the kind of teeming newsroom I joined when I first took a seat at The Sun‘s copy desk in 1986, but the accomplishment of the severely pared-down staff of a newspaper that has been undergoing repeated reductions in resources for more a decade and a half. That makes the staff’s accomplishment the more meaningful, the more remarkable.

My part in this achievement is minor compared to the work of the team of reporters and photographers who accomplished the work, or of the editors who encouraged and oversaw them. But many of the stories passed through my hands for a final look, a final check, before publication. As small a role as mine has been, I take pride that I contributed something toward the paper’s achievement, just as I took pride in having been a copy editor on many of the articles for which Diana Sugg won a Pulitzer Prize in 2003. We all do our part.

We are still working to provide readers with verified information about the world around them, information that they can use to make informed decisions. As the business environment of newspapers becomes more precarious, we have to work all the harder to accomplish that. And we do. We’re still here.

Categories: Uncategorized

What I do and why

January 10, 2019

Growing up in a minuscule town in eastern Kentucky, I was a good student, a teacher’s pet, and a bookworm.

Being a good student meant always having the right answer, and in English class, where I excelled, the right answer was always formal written English. I absorbed the dangerous belief that formal written English is “correct” English, all other forms being inferior at best, or downright wrong.

Consequently, I came to talk like a book and developed into a terrible language snob during adolescence and early adulthood, the worst kind of prescriptivist. It took some time for me to discover — through wide reading, through acquaintance with other editors in ACES: The Society for Editing, and through blogging exchanges with linguists and lexicographers — that language snobbery is no more noble, moral, or excusable than snobbery based on ancestry, place of birth, IQ score, wealth, physical beauty, or wardrobe.

This means I have had to revise, or even reverse, what I have told students in my editing class at Loyola University Maryland, but unlearning is an inescapable part of learning.

Over nearly forty years as an editor at newspapers, first The Cincinnati Enquirer and currently The Baltimore Sun, I have come to understand that my task is not to enforce a handful of superstitions and shibboleths, but to assist the writer in accomplishing their purpose. (Yes, singular their. Get over it.)

Accomplishing that purpose means making judgments rather than enforcing rules or rigidly adhering to a house style. The judgments involve balancing a set of interests: what is appropriate for the writer, appropriate for the subject, appropriate for the occasion, appropriate for the publication — and appropriate for the reader, the party most commonly overlooked.

That’s the job.

Categories: Uncategorized

Recent Posts

  • The Pulitzer came, and the glory shone around
  • What I do and why

Monthly Digest

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries RSS
  • Comments RSS
  • NAIWE

Latest Posts

The Pulitzer came, and the glory shone around

May 8, 2020

What I do and why

January 10, 2019

Contact Us

  • 804-476-4484
  • P.O. Box 412
    Montpelier, VA 23192-0412
Facebook Instagram Linkedin twitter

© NAIWE. All rights reserved. Designed by My House of Design.